S&OP: Streamlining Business Operations with Sales and Operations Planning

Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is a collaborative process that integrates sales, demand planning, and supply-chain planning functions within an organization. It serves as a bridge between these departments, aligning their activities to achieve a unified and synchronized approach to business planning and execution.

The primary role of S&OP is to establish a cohesive framework that enables effective decision-making, resource allocation, and demand-supply balancing. It brings together sales forecasts, production plans, inventory management, and financial projections to create an integrated plan that meets customer demand while optimizing operational efficiency and financial performance. Through S&OP, organizations can anticipate demand fluctuations, optimize production and inventory levels, and align resources and capacity to meet customer needs effectively. It enables proactive management of supply chain risks and helps organizations respond quickly to market changes or unforeseen events.

S&OP provides a structured framework that encourages collaboration and alignment across various departments, such as sales, operations, finance, and supply chain. It enables these teams to collectively assess and evaluate the impact of their decisions on the entire organization. By considering multiple perspectives and analyzing the interdependencies between functions, S&OP helps avoid siloed decision-making and fosters a more comprehensive and integrated approach. Moreover, S&OP allows organizations to evaluate different scenarios and conduct what-if analyses. 

Key Components of an Effective S&OP Process

Demand Planning

Demand Planning is the science of determining how much goods should an organization manufacture given the market demand, available inventory, and the production capacity such that no buyer goes unsold, and they are left with minimum or nil inventory on hand.

So it’s the Demand Planning team’s job to take forecasts from the sales team apply their judgement, use insights/ trends, and market information to finalize the supply plan. The higher their accuracy in forecasting “how much to produce”, the higher the chances of lower inventories and that the company is not leaving money on the table (missed sales).

Forecasting is one of the inputs into the demand plan. The demand planner will take into account the target, the previous purchase patterns by territory, customer, volume and adjust for the existing inventories to arrive at his final monthly demand plan. The challenge lies in bringing together all this data in a plan-able structure while at the same time being able to analyze on various parameters in order to be able to ascertain the final demand. Apart from analyzing historical trends the demand planning team also brings together external market research data to aid their decision-making. This plan can act as a sound overlay over the historical analysis. This is the starting point of the S&OP process and organizations need to balance the forecast with production such that they are minimizing slow moving stock and demurrage but at the same time delivering the goods on time as required by the customer. These 3 along with the forecast accuracy determine the impact of the Demand planners have on the organization’s top line and bottom line.

Supply Planning

Once the supply planner receives the demand plan he/she needs to take into account the constraints before finalizing the supply plan. Constrains with respect to production capacity, supplier capacity, and raw material lead times. While the capacity can be augmented by adding suppliers it cannot come at the cost of quality. In industries where the raw material is a natural resource like crude, minerals one needs to take into account sudden shortages by stocking adequate reserves.

The last step in this process is to finalize the monthly plan. Once the demand plan and the supply plan is determined all the relevant teams including sales, demand planning, supply planning, productions, procurements, and operations come together to finalize the monthly plan. Multiple informal deliberations later, each team offers its final best possible scenarios. Given the accuracy of the forecasts it will be rare to ensure that everyone gets what they want. Some customer deliverables may be impacted, production may have to ramp up slow-moving lines, supply teams may have need to look for new suppliers. All these options and variables are given due weightages begore agreeing on the final plan which is usually called the consensus pls. This is also the stage where system generated, statistical-modelling generated plan are also taken into consideration.

Benefits and Advantages of S&OP Implementation

As seen above, Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is a strategic business process that helps organizations align their sales and operations functions to achieve a balanced and integrated approach to decision-making. The implementation of S&OP offers several benefits and advantages, including:

Improved Forecast Accuracy: S&OP solution facilitates better demand planning by integrating inputs from various departments, resulting in improved forecast accuracy. This helps organizations optimize inventory levels, reduce stockouts, and enhance customer satisfaction.

Enhanced Supply Chain Visibility: S&OP system provides a holistic view of the entire supply chain, enabling organizations to identify potential bottlenecks, risks, and opportunities. This visibility allows proactive decision-making and better coordination between different functional areas, such as sales, operations, procurement, and logistics.

Efficient Resource Utilization: S&OP system enables organizations to align their resources, including labor, equipment, and materials, with anticipated demand. By optimizing resource allocation and utilization, organizations can improve productivity, reduce costs, and minimize waste.

Better Inventory Management: S&OP solution helps organizations achieve optimal inventory levels by aligning production plans with anticipated demand. This prevents overstocking or understocking situations, reduces carrying costs, and improves cash flow.

Enhanced Customer Satisfaction: With S&OP, organizations can ensure that they meet customer demands consistently and on time. By aligning sales forecasts, production plans, and inventory levels, companies can fulfill customer orders promptly, improve order fill rates, and strengthen customer relationships.

Strategic Decision Support: S&OP provides a platform for strategic decision-making by bringing together key stakeholders to discuss and evaluate various scenarios and options. This supports informed decision-making regarding capacity expansion, product portfolio changes, market entry or exit, and other strategic initiatives.

Financial Performance Improvement: Through better demand planning, inventory management, resource utilization, and decision-making, S&OP contributes to improved financial performance. It helps reduce costs, increase revenue through improved customer service, and optimize investment in resources and capacity.

The ultimate goal of Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is to achieve a balance between demand and supply within an organization. This equilibrium ensures that customer demand is met without excessive inventory or resource shortages. By aligning sales forecasts, production plans, and inventory management, S&OP aims to optimize operational efficiency while fulfilling customer needs. A harmonious balance between demand and supply enables organizations to enhance customer satisfaction, minimize costs, maximize profitability, and maintain a competitive edge in the market. Deflytics has executed multiple S&OP projects including one for speciality chemicals, another for agriculture producer, and one of a media broadcaster. We can help marry your objectives and processes to the right solution and deliver real-world business outcomes.

FAQs

What is the difference between S&OP and IBP?

S&OP primarily focuses on integrating sales and operations functions for short- to medium-term planning. It aims to balance demand and supply. On the other hand, IBP takes a broader perspective by integrating multiple functions, including finance, marketing, and supply chain, to align overall business plans and drive performance across a longer time horizon. IBP emphasizes financial integration, strategic planning, and cross-functional collaboration to achieve holistic and integrated decision-making.

How long does it take to implement S&OP?

A S&OP project implementation can take 3-8 months depending upon the scale of the organization, complexity of their processes, and the sub-processes involved.

What are the key success factors for S&OP?

While the key factors have been enumerated above, in short – collaborative processes scalable planning platform, and reliable data are 3 key success factors for S&OP.

Can S&OP help improve customer satisfaction?

Customer Delivery Index measures the on-time delivery of the agreed products to customers. By integrating all the relevant functions responsible for this KPI the S&OP process contributes directly to improving customer satisfaction.

Demand Planning : Your Guide to Demand Planning & Process

Whether you are manufacturing electronics or garments, or whether you are providing financial services or catering services. The starting point for all business is market demand – how many people will buy my products/service in the coming period?

Demand planning is the science of determining how much goods should an organization manufacture given the market demand, available inventory, and the production capacity such that no buyer goes unsold and they are left with minimum or nil inventory on hand. Fluctuating demand, supplier bandwidth, and production constraints- the three core factors that determine how much will be delivered to the customer by when. Demand planning is a system which brings together these 3 elements in a collaborative and transparent manner, overlays it by advancements in predictive modelling to improve their demand accuracy on an ongoing basis.

What Is Demand Planning & Its Importance?

If one does not do demand planning, there are two consequences – either they manufacture less and lose potential business or they manufacture more and are left with excess inventory. Both are not the outcomes any organization would want. While it’s not possible to be 100% accurate, the goal of demand planning is to come as close as possible to the market condition based on customer demand, market dynamics, historical data, stock in hand, and manufacturing constraints. So while the sales teams will be close to the customer and provide their view of how much they expect their customers to buy, Demand Planning role takes a deeper view of the expected demand and adjusts it for the factors mentioned above and develop the final plan. This final plan becomes the basis for supply-chain and production plan.

Demand planning sits in between sales and supply planning and plays a key role in ensuring organization is balancing its objectives between meeting demand and minimizing inventory.

Benefits of implementing demand planning in your business

Demand planning is probably the most challenging business objective to meet. But when done right it provides the best leverage an organization can have. The direct benefits include – Revenues or no business loss, and lower inventory holding costs. You are producing exactly what the market wants, nothing less .. nothing more. Indirect benefits include – customer satisfaction and repeat business. Because you are able to provide the customers what they want, and when they want it they will be satisfied and happy. This will lead to more repeat business which is generally serviced at a lower operational cost. Plus new business with other customers. Downstream impact – improved cash flow, reduced working capital requirement, and better utilization of plant capacity.

Conversely, if you are running your planning on spread sheets today, chances are that the demand planning team is wasting 60-75% of their time in activities such as data collation, version synchronization, macro manipulation, scenario creation, and cross-functional follow-ups. Impact – lengthy cycles, plan errors, static plans and most importantly stale analysis. Not to mention long working hours. Demand planning systems take away these mundane tasks and enable accelerated planning cycles, instantaneous P&Ls, reduced forecast errors, real-time visibility, and multi-dimensional analysis. And more.

Components, Steps, Common Challenges in demand planning

To accurately predict the demand for the forthcoming period – this is the objective of the demand planning team. And a complex one. To begin with, there are at least 4-5 different functions involved in this process – sales, demand plannings, supply planning, production, and delivery. Imagine if sales teams promise deliveries without knowing the stock and order status. Or the demand team creating the plan without knowledge of upcoming orders. Or the manufacturing team producing based on their available capacity alone. All the above scenarios will lead to unintended consequences – non-availability of goods for sale or over production of stocks not in demand.

Thus the planning process entails all the relevant teams collaborating to come up with a consensus plan. The process starts with the sales teams providing their sales forecasts for their territory/ customer. However they may not be able to give it at the grain and accuracy that is required. Plus they may not have knowledge about other factors which matter e.g. historical trend, seasonality, current inventory, and production schedule. E.g. salesperson A has the habit on over-estimating, territory-B is always shows slower offtake in Q2, or RM101 has a lead time of 6 weeks which will impact 8 SKUs. The demand planning team will look at these and many such variables in detail to come up with their demand plan.

A key component is the ability to develop multiple “what-if” scenarios in order to arrive at the final plan e.g. what if we increase the demand for SKU-145 by 1.5%, how will it impact other SKUs. Or what if we reduce the available capacity by 5%, how will it impact the quantities for other customers. Demand planning systems make this super easy for demand planners to visualize multiple scenarios and their impact on other parameters in order to arrive at the best decision.

The key challenges in this process are lack of visibility and collaboration across different stake holders, unavailability of timely historical data, and the time wasted by the demand planning team in collating the required data for analysis. Many a time the plan takes weeks to be frozen across teams, leading to poorer planning and forecast plans.

Apart from predicting the demand at the SKU level, the demand planning team is also the custodian of 3 other KPIs viz. SMS (slow moving stock), DND (detention and demurrage), and last CDI (customer delivery index). They need to balance the demand plan with these 3 objectives i.e. minimize SMS, DND and maximize CDI.

Tools and Software for Demand Planning

Understandably, spreadsheets are the first tools anyone uses for demand planning. While they support the early days, spreadsheets are not designed to handle the complexity, scale, collaboration and analytical capabilities required by the demand planning teams.
Demand planning needs to be executed in sync with the other related planning processes e.g. sales forecast, supply-chain plan, and production plan. Thus the planning solution should be able to support multiple use cases for the organization to be able to have all of their plans connected to one another.

Because Demand planning is essentially a prediction function the system should provide various forecasting models such as linear regression, additive decomposition, triple exponential smoothing, etc. It should have the ability to suggest the best fit model and provide sales forecast prediction. The system should have the ability to do forecast at aggregation level and then disaggregating at SKU level.

Apart from this the common expected capabilities include features such as spread sheet interface, multi-dimensional engine, analytics & dashboarding, and collaboration.

Best practices for demand planning

While the demand planning objectives remain consistent across organizations, they vary based on whether you are in B2B or B2C, whether you are in a MTO or MTS business. Some of the best practices include:

  • A defined and accepted process – Well understood roles and responsibilities, a shared consensus about the role and importance of the demand planning process, having a clear monthly schedule for all the teams to provide their respective rolling forecast numbers, a consistent template which all the stake holders can adhere to,
  • SKU/ account level planning – As they say the devil is in the detail. It’s always possible to get summary data from the detailed data but not the other way round. So wherever possible do the demand planning at a SKU/account level. At least of major products/customers. This will enable to organization to decipher the trends better and reason the factors attributing to the demand.
  • 3 demand plans – While this may seem a lot of effort a practice of developing multiple scenarios is easily enabled by a planning tool. One could be your best-case plan, second one as the more realistic case, and the third one as the worst-case plan. All together culminating into an overall agreed consensus plan.
  • Cross-functional collaboration – This is key to a successful plan. Every department will have its priorities and constrains – the sales team wants to sale more, the production teams wants to utilize its capacity to the fullest and the finance team wants to ensure that the organization is not missing its financial KPIs. When you offer visibility into the assumptions and drivers to everyone concerned there is a likely output which is in the best interest of the organization., and lastly bring together all the stakeholder and jointly develop the final consensus plan.

Conclusion
What is your monthly demand forecast accuracy? If you are able to answer this question and monitor it month-on-month you will be able to find newer ways of improving it. Every single percentage point improvement can mean a revenue impact of millions. A Demand planning solution will ensure that you are capturing more market share and optimizing your costs and inventory.

FAQ

Q. What is demand planning, and why is it important?

Ans. Imagine a customer walks into your store but you do not have what he wants OR you have lots of quantities of another product which no one is asking for. Demand planning helps you solve this problem and that’s why its so crucial to any business.

Q. What are some of the components of demand planning?

Ans. Sales forecast, current inventory, production capacity, seasonality, and historical trends are some of the components that go into making the demand plan.

Q. What are the key steps involved in demand planning?

Ans. Capturing the sales forecast, normalizing it using past data and predictive techniques, comparing with trends/seasonality, and considering inventory and production capacity are the key steps involved in demand planning.

Q. How does demand planning differ from sales forecasting?

Ans. Sales forecasting is done by the sales team listing the orders they expect from their customers in the coming months. The demand planning team will use the sales forecast as a starting point for their process and develop the final demand plan taking into account other factors such as trends, seasonality, inventory, capacity, etc.

Q. What are some demand forecasting techniques that businesses can use?

Ans. Liner regression, triple exponential smoothing, additive decomposition, and winter’s multiplicative are some of the statistical techniques used for forecasting.

Q. What are some challenges that businesses may face in demand planning?

Ans. Not having proper sales forecasts, inability to analyze past data, inability to bring together all the data required for planning purposes, providing trustworthy visibility to relevant stake holders are some of the challenges in the demand planning process.

Q. What role do technology and software tools play in demand planning?

Ans. Doing demand planning without software tools is akin to traveling to a destination without using navigation maps – you will get to your destination but it will cost you more time and money.


Read More: WORKFORCE PLANNING GUIDE: DEFINITION, IMPORTANCE & BEST PRACTICES